DIDACTICS I
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Newsletter 12 23rd November 2001
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Universidad Tecnológica
Nacional
Instituto Nacional
Superior del Profesorado Técnico
Cátedra de Didáctica
Especial del Primer y Segundo Ciclo de la EGB
Profesores: Omar
Villarreal, Fernando Armesto, Claudia Alvarez.
&
Adriana Lauri.
Instituto Superior de
Formación Docente Nro 41 – Adrogué.
Profesor : Omar
Villarreal
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Start by doing what's
necessary, then what's possible and suddenly you are doing the impossible."
Saint Francis of Assisi
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear All,
This is our
last issue this year. The second parcial is over and today we will have our
make-up (there might be those who will be playing hard risking everything
in a February make-up). Still there are
a few summaries to publish. So here we are again.
This has
been a tough year. But it was not so bad after all… we had you, our families
and friends and our blessed job to make it better.
A big hug to you all
Omar
Villarreal
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Campolonghi, Laureana
Activity-based teaching
Topic centred learning
Through a
topic the children are guaranteed interesting content, a share context and
emphasis on meaning. These provides a genuine purpose for learning. Language
becomes a passport to finding out, to increasing their knowledge. If a topic
chosen is directly relevant to children´s experiences or interests, topic
centred learning can be made more meaningful to them.
Children are irrepressible doers. It´s by
doing that they learn. Various forces stimulate children into activity, most
evident among them play, creativity and curiosity. In play, children are active
symbol-makers, imitators or actors. Within the safety of the play situation
they try things out in their fantasy and imagination. Children want to make
things for themselves. They are also curious, they want to experiment, find
out. In the language classroom, the teacher can exploit what children naturally
do. Activity-based learning is focus on the language skills to be learned. The
activities within their language curriculum should enhance their cognitive and
manual skills as well as to develop their target language skills.
Planning the topic
The teacher first needs to choose a topic
that is appropriate for her group of pupils. The topic needs to be wide enough
to appeal to varying interests and levels of ability and perhaps both boys and
girls.
Having decided a topic we have to produce a
topic web, it´s a free exploration of ideas expected to cover, identifying
language structures, activities, and so on. There are several different kinds
of activities. Activities can include one or more cognitive skills such as
describing, identifying, matching, classifying, and so on. Children finds tasks
which are challenging more interesting than those with obvious solutions. The
most challenging learning activities are open-ended activities, where the
outcome or answers are not known. The children become real learners, where they
have to think rather than simply remember. The open-ended activities tend to
allow for greater creativity and responsability. With closed activities the
solutions are known. They are used to check their own work.
The teacher´s role
The teacher have to introduce new language
and provide practice with repetition in order to consolidate what is learned.
The teacher needs to consider the following issues: preparing the children,
language support, strategies for managing the classroom and a system of
feedback and assessment. The children need to be prepared linguistically to
give them confidence to use English. This involves initial input and ongoing
support and feedback. The teacher creates learning situations where children
must use the target language structure but also are challenged.
Activity-centred learning frequently involves group work. The teacher may need
to interrupt and activity to teach and reinforce a language point. By creating
the opportunity for groups to share their tasks and end-results, the teacher
enables the children to provide feedback for each other. In closed activities,
the children can assess their own achievement by matching their results with
predicted outcome, while the teacher keeps the overview of pupil´s competence
and progress
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
De Felice, María José
The role of fun and games activities in teaching young learners
It´s common place that young children learn
better through play or at least can be induced to go along with teaching that
is tempered by fun activities. We might all take care about exactly what the
children are absorbed in.
Fun should have the role in rather than
just be feature of children´s education.
Here are
some pitfalls:
-
Aboard
game whose rules are not complicated that the children are more absorbed in its
mechanics than in the language comprehension or production work that was
originally designed to stimulte little English and a lot of native language
will be heard.
-
Some
teachers are afraid of playing because they feel that children may be out of
control. For these cases there are two messages to the teacher:
First,
we need to monitor what is actually going on the class.
Second,
we need to develop a clear understanding of the mechanics and effects of
different activity types.
Fun activities should form part of the
skills, conceptual and cultural, social development of the child.
Rigorous grammatical analysis does not seem
to be appropiate to all the children, though discovery of the rules may be
useful pay-off of pleasant informal activities.
Language pay-off is one of the most obvious
parameters to consider.
Some games can promote general educational
benefits like concentration, close listening and memory strategies.
Picture dominoes
This is a game which demands both lateral and
logical thinking together with an expression of that thinking in English.
Students have to put a set of different
pictures cards into a chain in which each card has some link with the one next
to it . The links may be obvious or it can be the products of an individual
child´s imagination or opinion.
The main point is that the link must be
expressed in English before the move can be made. This game can be played using
the normal rules of dominoes ( one dominoes per turn, the first player to
finish is the winner) but its works just as well even better if the students
co-operate in building up the most satisfying chain, helping each other with
ideas and language.
Dot-to-dot puzzle
This game where the numbers are given as
words or as letters of the alphabet can provide useful reinforcement for number
and letter work. There is an additional language pay-off if the child then has
to write under the solved puzzle: “ This is a …”
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Analía
Alvarado
1
What is good primary practice?
Jean
Brewster, Ealing College, England
Nunan
(1988) writes of the benefits to be derived from applying general educational
theory and research to language teaching:
Although
theoretical linguistics is an important base discipline, it is not the only
discipline which has anything of value to contribute to decision-making on
what, how and when to teach.
There are other features which all contribute to our understanding of good educational practice in the teaching of English to young children.
How do
children think and learn?
Primary
education has been influenced by attempts to discover the ways in which people
think and learn, in Britain.
|
Piaget
(1967) |
Bruner (1962) |
Vygotsky (1966) |
|
The three
stages: (ascertained by means of cognitive tasks) sensori-motor’ (birth to 18 months approx.) ‘concrete
operational’ (18 months to 11 years approx.) It’s subdivided into two periods: -the ‘pre-operational’ which lasts until around the age of seven : the ‘concrete operations are being prepared for; and –the ‘operational’: They are established and consolidated. ‘formal
operation’ period (11 years onwards) Piaget
was primarily interested in the structure of mature thinking. Both
Piaget and Bruner, emphasise the importance of action and problem- solving
in learning and believe that abstract thinking should grow out of and be
abstracted from material actions. Piaget
and Vygotsky differed in their views on the nature of language and its effect
on intellectual development. Piaget argued that language exerts no formative
effects on the structure of thinking: mental actions and operations are
derived from action, not talk. |
Concept
of Language Acquisition Support
System (LASS). Bruner: ‘For
language development there needs to be a child component , incorporating an
innate propensity for active social interaction and language learning,
together with an adult support and help component.’ The
interactional partner provides a structure or framework which Bruner calls ‘scaffolding’. While
Bruner sought to describe the
different Processes that are implicated in problem-solving. From
both, Piaget’s and Bruner’s perspectives, teaching that teaches children only
how to manipulate abstract procedureswithout first establishing the deep
connections between such procedures and the activities involved in the
solution of
concrete problems is bound to fail. Bruner
and Vygotsky place a greater emphasis than Piaget on role of language, communication and instruction in the development
of knowledge and understanding . Bruner’s view: ‘Children’s language and
learning development takes place through the processes of social interaction.’ |
Vygotsky
argued that in the beginning speech serves a communicative function; later it transforms the way in which children think, learn and understand.
It becomes an instrument of thought, providing the means by which planning
and self-regulation to achieve goals takes place. Thus speech forms the highest mental processes, including the
ablility to plan, evaluate, memorise and reason. These processes are culturally formed in social
interaction. Language gives structure
to and directs the processes of thinking and concept formation
themselves. Vygotsky:’
intelligence’ is the capacity to learn through instruction. The ‘ zone of
proximal development’ (ZPD) is the distance between the actual developmental
level as determined by independent
problem-solving and the level of potential development as determined through
problem-solving under adult guidance. This theory emphasises the social nature of
knowledge acquisition. |
How have these theories influenced primary
classrooms?
These are the main features of primary practice
in Britain between the 1960s and 1980s:
a) Teacher autonomy.
b) A child-centred curriculum and
methodology. This
led to a concern for the education of the whole child, including his/her moral,
physical, emotional and intellectual growth.
c) Individualised learning, where children were free to work at their own
level and pace.
d) A topic-based approach, developed out of child-centredness
and emphasising the integration of different aspects of the curriculum.
e) A methodology whose emphasis was
‘learning by doing’
and problem-solving, involving frequent use of work in small groups.
Today primary practice in Britain is undergoing
enourmous change following the introduction of the National Curriculum. In the
recent past Britain has been proud of its tradition of ‘child-centred’ primary
education based on a flexible curriculum which was not assessment-driven.
There are now real fears that child-centred
education may become a thing of the past as teaching falls under the grip of
national testing.
The Department of Education and Science (DES)
document (1989) lists the features which, in the teaching of English, are held
to represent good primary practice, a term which is frequently used but rarely
defined.
1 Using language to make, receive and
communicate meaning, in purposeful contexts.
2 An ‘apprenticeship’ approach to acquiring
written and oral language, in which the adult represents the ‘success’ the
child seeks and yet offers endless help.
3 Maximum encouragement and support whilst errors are mastered; the
appreciation that mistakes are necessary to learning.
4 Working on tasks which the children have chosen and which they direct for themselves.
5 Employing a variety of forms with a clear awareness of audience.
6 Working with teachers who are themselves involved in the process- talkers, listeners, readers.
7 Reading literature for enjoyment, responding to it critically and using that reading for learning.
Many EFL teachers would probably agree with most of these points. Points 1 to 5 in line with the Communicative approach to ELT and views on process writing.
Points 2 and 3 state that risk-taking is important in children’s learning and that the making of mistakes can reveal the evidence of learning rather than being detrimental to learning. As Mayor writes, ‘the important thing is that a
child should be given the space to experiment and take risks with the language, on the principle that fluency is more likely to lead to accuracy than vice versa.’
Point 4 is more controversial and probably represents the kind of classroom activity which is viewed as typically British, but not always! Point 6 has emerged from the teaching of literacy: if children see teachers reading with enjoyment, they are more motivated to develop their own literacy. Point 7 is related to the importance of stories and rhymes in children’s learning and their frequent use I
primary EFL classrooms.
The DES report includes a note on classroom organisation: ‘Effective English teaching may occur where a whole class listens attentively or engages in a lively question and answer session; in small group teaching in which a high degree of interaction is possible; and in one-to-one setting where a child may receive individual help and support.’
How do children learn a foreign
language?
Ellis suggests that there are eight features of classroom discourse which may be important in SLD
(Second language development). These features can be grouped thus:
The teacher’s use of language
1 Quantity of intake
2 An input rich in directives
3 An input rich in ‘extending’ utterances
Types of activity used and support provided
4 A need to communicate
5 Adherence to the ‘here and now’ principle
The learner’s use of language
6 Independent control of the propositional content
7 The performance of a range of speech acts
8 Uninhibited practice
The first three features concern the nature of the language input. Qualitative and quantitive aspects of the speech addressed to a child are important in both FLD (first language development ) and SLD. We have seen how theories of children’s learning require that young learners be supported by moving from the concrete to the abstract and through being involved in activity.
Point 2 is useful since it requires a non-verbal response and refers to concrete features of the Environment which makes decoding of the propositional content easier. Many primary EFL classrooms use the approach to ELT called ‘total physical response’ (TPR), which is one means of providing an input rich in directives.
The second group of features with the types of language activity in which the learner is engaged.
Point 4 refers to the need for language teaching to be based on purposeful communication.
Point 5 refers to the need to move from the concrete to the abstract in order to support children’s understanding of the propositional content of a message.
The third group of features concerns the types of language used by the learner. Ellis suggest that SLD is likely to be more successful if children are free in the foreign language learning context to initiate interaction as well as respond to others’ use of language.
To ensure that children have the opportunity to use a wide range of language, teachers must include a variety of task types based on games, stories, collaborative problem-solving of information-gap activities which will provide wherever possible a context and audience for the production of spoken
and written language.
How can children be helped to learn a
foreign language?
Wood (1988) explains the ways in which younger children are more ‘distractable’ than older ones,
Writing that the ability to keep on task and to ignore distractions is a symptom of the child’s intellect, and changes in concentration span are related to intellectual development.
Vygotsky argued that mature mental activity involves adaptive ‘self-regulation’ which develops through social interaction. Wood writes: ‘Attending, concentrating and memorising are activities.
Simply asking a child aged five or six to pay attention, concentrate, study, learn or remenber is unlikely to bear fruit. Unless we embody the material to be learned and remembered in a task that makes sense to the child, one that involves objectives (he/she) can realise that draws (his/her) attention ‘naturally’ to the elements we wish (him/her) to take in, our imperatives to concentrate,
memorise or learn are almost bound to fail.
Wood gives an example of children being asked to memorise the names of toy animals. If they are asked to point to and verbally label each animal, they are more likely to be able to remember the names than when simply asked to remember the names without accompanying actions.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Laura Capararo
GAMES FOR CHILDREN. Lewis, Gordon and Bedson, Gunther
WHY USE GAMES IN THE EFL (English as a Foreign Language) CLASSROOM?
Through games children experiment, discover, and interact with their environment. Games add variation to a lesson and increase motivation by providing an incentive to use the TARGET LANGUAGE.
WHAT IS A LANGUAGE GAME?
What differentiates language games from other activities in the EFL classroom is the presence of a set of rules which guide the children´s actions, and an element of strategy (children must successfully apply their language skills). Children are required to make individual choices based on a specific language crieria which form part of the rules.
THE KEY TO A SUCCESSFUL LANGUAGE: the rules must be clear and the game must be fun but always KEEP THE LANGUAGE COMPONENT AT THE FOREFRONT OF YOUR PLANNING.
INTEGRATING GAMES INTO THE SYLLABUS: games can supplement the core material or replace activities you dislike.
USES OF LANGUAGE GAMES:
1) to introduce new material
2) to practise recently learnt language items
3) to relax or energize a class: ROUSERS wake up a class (movement games and competitive games). SETTLERS calm a class down (craft activities and games focus on listening)
PLAY DIFFERENT GAMES FROM LESSON TO LESSON : do not overdo a game
VARY THE ORDER IN WHICH YOU PLAY GAMES: avoid repetitive routines (song-drill-game-craft, song-drill-game-craft) You can INSERT THE GAME WHEN ENERGY AND UNDERSTANDING ARE AT THEIR BEST.
THINK AHEAD: the best designed game will backfire if you are not fullu sure about all aspects of the activity.
MAKING GAMES INTO PART OF THE SYLLABUS:
games creation involves many skills as well as active decision making on the
part of the children. It is a rich field in which to practise some basic English.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Karina V.
La Banca(morning shift) Didactics
I
English as a foreign language in primary level: the search for content
Ray
Tongue
compares:
TRADITIONAL
METHOD ENGLISH
LANGUAGE
TEACHING FROM A
COMMUNICATIVE
APPORACH
Learners
have to
know
about the language
Know the language
Forma of
the target language Language as means of
METHODS:
communication
Audio
lingual
Oral -
structural
Structural-situational
They take
the sentence as a unit of
Instruction
Exemplification
and practice of the
Grammatical
system through isolated
and
uncontextualised sentences
Difficulty
in 2nd language learners with
some
features: article system, anaphoric
reference, sequence, tenses, connectives,
stylistic choices "intersentential
features",
they belong to the whole text and not to
the
individual sentence, they cannot be
taught by an
approach which focuses
exclusively
on the sentence.
They pay
little attention to the language
Language used to communicate
function
and equally little to the purposes
for which
the language is being learnt
Meaning
subordinated to form
Meaning is the main point
Programmes:
language being used for the
Specify what the learner should
purpose of
teaching language be
able to do with target language
"Children
are asked to speak speaking" at
different stages "Children
Focuses on language ignoring the
learner speak something to some
purpose.
“pupils are
picking up small parts of the
language
machinery”
TENOR:
teaching English for not specific
reason
Difficulty
of establishing credible performance
Objectives: specific and precisely defined objectives
He proposes
four approaches to primary English
Problem
of content rather than objectives
Cophinathan
of Singapore pointed, "Content of language courses has to be organized in
relation to the functional range of the language in question in society
concerned, which it is not easy to determine (in the case Hong Kong)
Worldwide
English is the language of Science and Technology
So Science
for example is likely to be taught in English many of the scientific vocabulary
has borrowed widely from English.
Language
items: have/ has Can/cannot
Examples
"This
is a cat
It is
brown
It has 4
legs
"Peter,
can you touch the floor? Yes. I can"
Tom, can
you touch the ceiling? No, I can't"
Content-based
extracts offer material of greater interest
This is
a balsam plant
It is
red
It has
leaves
Magnets
Can a
magnet attract paper clip?
Can it
attract pencils?
The 2 first
extracts demonstrate how in language
work, the second ones, do the same but
tells the learner something he didn’t know before.
2) To
scan primary curriculum for appropriate
English teaching
Learners
explore through their mother tongue (integrative parts) the world and use
English to have a second look at appropriate parts of their world (the
instrumental parts). So certain topics of the syllabus are suitable:
public transport, clothing worn in other lands, countries of the world, postal and telephone services, newspaper and TV.
Put the
English into a "language and other arts"
With
concentration on games, puzzles, verses, stories, competitions, dramatizations,
quizzes together with songs and music, coloring, tracing, composing pictures,
and other artistic activities of various kinds
"The
excessive control of language, otherwise is the main reason for the dull of
primary language teaching material
A
combination of all approaches
The ones
sketched above might offer an attractive body of content for primary English-
" It id the language that determines the content of the lesson and not
vise versa.
Learner
interest, enjoyment and successful use of language for particular communicative
tasks should have priority over structural grading and other matters related to
linguistic forms.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Graciela Bilbao
A COURSE IN LANGUAGE TEACHING PRACTICE AND THEORY BY PENNY UR
MODULE 5 TEACHING VOCABULARY
UNIT 1 WHAT IS VOCABULARY?
Words we teach in the foreign language BUT a new item
may be more than a single word (Post‑office) SO it's better to talk about
Vocabulary 'ITEMS' instead OF 'WORDS'.
WHAT NEEDS TO BE TAUGHT?
. Form
• Grammar
• Collocation
• Aspects of meaning * Denotation
• Connotation
• Appropriateness
• Word formation
UNIT 2 WAYS OF PRESENTING NEW VOCABULARY
Concise definition
Detailed description
Examples
Illustration
Demonstration
Context
Synonyms
Antonyms
Translation
Associated ideas, collocations
UNIT 4 IDEAS
FOR VOCABULARY WORK IN THE CLASSROOM
BRAINSTORMING IDENTIFYING
WORDS
ROUND AN IDEA WE
KNOW
MODULE 6
TEACHING GRAMMAR
UNIT 1 WHAT IS GRAMMAR?
In general: A set of rules that define how words are
combined or changed to form acceptable units of meaning within a language.
Grammatical Structures: A specific instance of grammar
is usually called a 'structure'. (The Past Tense, Noun Plurals, etc.) Grammar
does not only affect how units of language are combined to 'look right', it
also affects their meaning.
UNIT 4 PRESENTING AND EXPLAINING GRAMMAR
GUIDE
Include both oral and written forms, form and meaning.
Provide enough examples. A simple generalization rather than a detailed grammar‑book
definition. Speak and write clearly. Appropriate speed. Decide whether a rule
would be helpful or not.
UNIT 5 TYPES OF GRAMMAR PRACTICE ACTIVITIES
Awareness
Controlled drills
Meaningful drills
Guided, meaningful practice
Free sentence composition
Discourse composition
Free discourse
‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑
MODULE 8 TEACHING
LISTENING
UNIT 1 WHAT
DOES REAL‑LIFE LISTENING INVOLVE?
LISTENING SITUATIONS
Interview Theatre show
Instructions
Telephone chat
Loudspeaker announcements
Lesson, lecture
Radio news
Conversation, gossip
Committee meeting
Watching television
Shopping
Story‑ telling
CHARACTERISTICS OF REAL‑LIFE LISTENING
SITUATIONS
1 Informal
Spoken Discourse:
FEATURES
Brevity of 'chunks'
Pronunciation
Vocabulary
Grammar
'Noise'
Redundancy
Non‑repetition
2 LISTENER EXPECTATIONS AND PURPOSE
3 LOOKING AS WELL AS LISTENING
4 ONGOING, PURPOSEFUL LISTENER RESPONSE
5 SPEAKER ATTENTION
UNIT 2 REAL‑LIFE
LISTENING IN THE CLASSROOM
Classroom listening is not real life listening but
it's useful to provide students with training in listening
comprehension. Listening activities based] on
simulated real‑life situations are more motivating and
interesting.
GUIDELINES
1 Listening
Texts
Informal talk
Speaker visibility, direct speaker‑listener
interaction
2 Listening
Tasks:
Single exposure
Expectations
Purpose
Ongoing listener response
UNIT 4 TYPES
OF ACTIVITIES
1 NO OVERT
RESPONSE: Stories, Songs and
Entertainment (film, videos, theatre)
2 SHORT
RESPONSES
Obeying instructions
Ticking off items
True/ False
Detecting mistakes
Cloze
Guessing definitions
Skimming and Scanning
3 LONGER
RESPONSES
Answering questions
Note‑ taking
Paraphrasing translating
Summarizing
Long gap‑filling
4 EXTENDED
RESPONSES
• Problem ‑ solving
•Interpretation
MODULE 9 TEACHING SPEAKING
UNIT 1 SUCCESSFUL ORAL FLUENCY PRACTICE
CHARACTERISTICS
Learners talk a lot
Participation is even
Motivation is high
Language is of an acceptable level
PROBLEMS WITH SPEAKING ACTIVITIES
• Inhibition
• Nothing to say
• Low or uneven participation
• Mother‑tongue use
WHAT TO DO TO AVOID THESE PROBLEMS?
• Use group work
• Base the activity on easy language
• Careful choice of topic and task to stimulate
interest
• Give some instruction or training in discussion
skills
• Keep students speaking the target language
UNIT 2 THE
FUNCTIONS OF TOPIC AND TASK
TOPIC: A good topic is one to which learners can
relate using ideas from their own experience and
Knowledge.
TASK: A task is essentially goal ‑oriented.
UNIT 3 DISCUSSION ACTIVITIES
• Describing pictures
• Picture differences
• Things in common
• Shopping list
• Solving a problem
MODULE 10 TEACHING READING
UNIT 1 HOW DO
WE READ?
SOME ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT THE NATURE OF READING
We need to perceive and decode letters in order to
read words
We need to understand all the words in order to
understand the meaning of a text. The more symbols (letters or words) there are
in a text, the longer it will take to read it. We gather meaning from what we
read. Our understanding of a text comes from understanding the words of which
it is composed.
UNIT 3 TYPES OF READING ACTIVITIES
IDEAS FOR READING ACTIVITIES
Pre‑question
Do‑it‑yourself questions
Provide a title
Summarize
Continue
Preface
Gapped text
Mistakes in the text
Comparison
Responding
Representation of content
UNIT 4 IMPROVING READING SKILLS
Getting learners to understand a simple text is only
the beginning. Reading skills need to be fostered so that they can cope with
more and more sophisticated texts and tasks, and deal with them efficiently.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Let your students choose their own simplified readers
and give them time to read them. The vocabulary must be familiar. Words unknown
can he either easily guessed or safely ignored. Give interesting tasks before
asking learners to read. The task must encourage selective, intelligent reading
for the main meaning (not trivial details). Allow students to manage without
understanding every word. Provide variety of texts and tasks.
MODULE 11 TEACHING WRITING
UNIT 2 TEACHING PROCEDURES
The purpose of writing is the expression of ideas but
the writer needs also to pay some attention to formal aspects: handwriting,
spelling, punctuation and of course, acceptable grammar and vocabulary. One of
the problems in teaching writing is to maintain a fair balance between content
and form but this 'fair balance' depends on our own teaching situation and
opinion.
CLASSIFYING WRITING ACTIVITIES
WRITING:
AS AN END IN ITSELF
AS MEANS AND END
AS A MEANS
UNIT 3 TASKS THAT STIMULATE WRITING
Some textbook writing activities are:
Write a report or a review of a book. Write an
instruction sheet. (Prepare food) Write a narrative or a personal story
Describe a view / someone / people. Answer a letter. Job application, etc.
Sometimes tasks given in textbooks do Not always
stimulate writing effectively. That's why it's useful to take into account
these CRITERIAS.
SOME CRITERIA FOR THE EVALUATION OF TEXTBOOK WRITING
ACTIVITIES
• Is the
activity motivating, stimulating and interesting to do?
• Is it of
an appropriate level for them? (easy ‑‑ difficult / childish –
sophisticated)
• Is the
kind of writing relevant to their needs?
• Is it
necessary to do some preliminary teaching in preparation for this activity?
• Do I
like this activity? Would I use it?
UNIT 5 GIVING FEEDBACK ON WRITING
PROBLEMS: 1) WHAT SHOULD FEEDBACK BE MAINLY ON:
LANGUAGE? CONTENT? ORGANIZATION?
We should correct language mistakes without conveying
the message that these are the main basis for evaluation. We may correct
mistakes and make suggestions as to content and organization, but not evaluate,
and give the evaluation only on the basis of the rewritten, polished version.
2) SHOULD ALL MISTAKES BE CORRECTED?
The correcting of mistakes is part of the language
instruction but too much of it can be discouraging and demoralizing. We might
correct only mistakes that actually affect meaning.
3) SHOULD LEARNERS REWRITE, INCORPORATING CORRECTIONS?
Rewriting is very important because it reinforces
learning and it's an integral part of the writing process as a whole, BUT if we
demand rewriting we must reread and value what they have done; so it's better
to consider the first version as provisional and regard the final one as ' THE'
assignment.
4) SHOULD WE LET STUDENTS CORRECT OR GIVE FEEDBACK ON
EACH OTHER'S WRITTEN WORK?
In general , peer correction can be useful but it
doesn't release us from tile duty of checking and evaluating student writing.
They can work together on their first drafts and then rewrite and give the
final version to the teacher but the question of personal relationships is not
a problem that can be solved by particular teaching techniques. It depends on
the general classroom climate.
VOCABULARY GRAMMAR PRACTICE ACTIVITIES
*Awareness
read an article. find and underline examples
*Controlled drills write statements about John. follow
the example:
John drinks tea but he doesn't drink coffee
*Meaningful drills
choose someone you know very well and write true
statements
about them according to the following example
he/ she likes ice cream
he/ she doesn't like ice cream
*Guided, meaningful practice
write sentences according to a set pattern using your
own words
if 1 had a million dollars... what would you do?
*(structure based) free sentence composition
Describe a picture using the appropriate tense
*(structure based) discourse composition
give a dilemma situation and ask to recommend a
solution. they are
directed to include modals
*Free discourse
they are given no specific direction to use the
structure. they don't
receive the final direction
LISTENING ACTIVITIES
follow instructions
listen to a recorded talk and then answer the multiple
choice
questions below
SPEAKING ACTIVITIES.
describing pictures
picture differences
things in common
shopping list
solving a problem
READING ACTIVITIES.
answering comprehension questions (after reading a
text)
answer questions before reading the text and then
check
try to find mistakes
fill in the gaps
provide a title
continue the story
summarize
WRITING ACTIVITIES.
write:
a report of a book
a letter
an instruction sheet (how to prepare a meal)
about a personal experience
about your favourite pop star
about your best friend
imagine your ideal school
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
v What do we mean
by informal interaction?
By informal interaction we mean the exchange of ideas, using spoken English between teachers and learners and among learners themselves.
Besides that, in informal interaction the language is used for functions, which are labelled social functions such as greetings, discussing health, attendance, the weather and so on.
According to Fanselow, there are four main content areas in most lessons.
1. Language: this area covers the part of the lesson in which the teacher is explaining or illustrating the language and the pupils are asking questions about the language or practising pronunciation or structures.
2. Procedure: this part of the lesson is when the teacher is managing the class, explaining what to do next, how to do it and so on.
3. Subject –Matter: it is when the language is being used to convey some specific topic as part of the lesson. For example: if the teacher tells the story of “The very hungry caterpillar”, the subject-matter might be food or the past tense but the content area of language is not the food or the past tense, but the story of a caterpillar which at the end of the story turns into a beautiful butterfly.
4. Life: this area concerns about real life matters not directly about the lesson. For instance: the teacher can ask a pupil who has nothing to write on.: where is your notebook?
v Why should we
encourage informal interaction in English?
There are four main arguments for this question:
1. Children learn languages best in situations where their attention is focussed on meaning rather than on language.
2. Teachers must provide their pupils with opportunities to use the language in real situations.
3. Meaning is communicated more directly in informal settings, so unfamiliar vocabulary is more easily understood when the objects under discussion are present in the surroundings. For instance: the use of realia in the classroom.
4. If we want English to come naturally we must demonstrate to the children that English is a means of communication in the same way that their mother tongue.
The interaction hypothesis proposed by Allwright states that “the nature of the linguistic interaction a learner engages in, will affect the speed and quality of the learning.
We have to take into account that different learners require different types of interaction to succeed; however, engaging in spoken interaction is a necessary stage for all learners who hope to use language for speaking outside the classroom.
v How can we encourage informal interaction?
There are some strategies that a teacher can do to achieve this.
1. Opportunities for interaction
In the absence of regular meetings with English speakers, it is the teacher who has to use the target language to communicate so the children would be likely to use the language freely in real interaction.
If the teacher uses language freely in informal situations, learners will have the advantage of a proper model of language use.
The types of events that are suitable for informal interaction depend very much on the age and interests of the children, but there are certain principles, which can be applied with children of any age.
Ø One principle is that informal interaction is incidental, that is to say that is not central to the lesson
Ø Another principle to take into account is that is not necessary for all children to be involved in the interaction. Remarks addressed to individuals or small groups can be just as useful as remarks addressed to the whole class.
Ø These remarks should be made meaningful by context; these can be achieved by using gestures, mime, facial expressions and so on.
There are a number of topics, which are particularly appropriate for informal interaction. For instance: life events such as birthdays, festivals. holidays, etc.
2. Extending language classroom
This is another strategy that a teacher can take to encourage informal interaction. By extending language classroom we mean that the English teacher can work in close relation with other teachers.
3.
Interaction between the
children
Teachers have to promote role play as a classroom activity. The principle behind role play is clear: to provide children with the chance to use language in specific situations, for example: in a shop, at the dentist’s
4. The maintenance of communication between teachers and pupils
Many teachers use what is known about interaction in order to help maintain communication with the class. It can be very helpful if teachers train learners early in the use of such expressions as: I’m sorry, I don’t understand, What’s the English for...? and so on
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PETRONCZAK
FLORENCIA
Video can be used for a wide variety of purposes. It presents language in context and can show the meaning of words. It can bring fun and added motivation to language learning.
It
can do this because video combines sound and vision. And all the elements of
sound and vision can and should be exploited for the young learner. On the visual side, there are
people, objects and their characteristics; there is movement, colour, shape. On
the soundtrack, we have music and effects, as well as language. In the cartoon
form, all of these things are particularly strong and clear. The situations,
gestures and intonation are naturally exaggerated and are therefore clearer and
easier to understand.
Finally,
the content is more memorable, and so what is being taught should be more
effectively learnt.
v
HOW SHOULD WE USE IT ?
Show short extracts. Something between one and five minutes can generate at least one
or two lessons.
Show whole of extract first. It would seem that children do not respond well to stop-start
techniques, they like to see what is going to happen, so go back and practise
rather than stop and practise.
View actively. Set a task
v
HOW CAN VIDEO BE USED FOR ?
Some of the tasks one might use with the
video are:
COMPREHENSION
(1)_ Gist questions. Set one or two gist
questions before they watch
(2)_ Recognising emotions. Get the children
to concentrate on the emotions expressed by what the characters say and the way
they say it. Before they watch ask them to find out for example: “ Who is
angry?, Who is sad ?
(3)_ Sentence re-ordering. Write sentences
and make sure the children understand them, before they watch. Then they watch
the scene and have to put the events (sentences) in the right order.
(4)_ Prediction. You explain that you are
going to show them a short scene and they must guess what happens next.
LANGUAGE
DEVELOPMENT
You
might want to develop the ways of expressing likes and dislikes, to revise
colour words or to develop the description of the characteristics, perhaps
trough comparatives.
PRESENTATION
Video
is a very effective way of presenting new items of language because of its
combination of sound and vision.
USING VIDEO AS A MODEL
(1)_ Repetition
(2)_ Imitation
(3)_ Chanting
(4)_ Singing
(5)_ Re-enactment
GETTING THEN TO TALK
In getting children to talk by using video,
two techniques can be useful.
Sound only:
As well as asking children to describe people, you may ask “ What is happening
?
Silent viewing: This is the opposite technique: you show the picture without the
sound and ask the children to work out what is happening or who the characters
are.
Video can provide a model and be a good springboard for a whole range of activities: Drawing, Writing, Role-play and Models.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------